The purpose of the Falmouth Wind Turbine Option Analysis Process (WTOP) is to engage in an open, transparent, and collaborative exploration of the range of options for the long-term future of the Town’s two Wind Turbines – Wind I and Wind II.
The tasks of the WTOP are to:
- Clarify the range of potentially acceptable long-term options
- Identify the questions that would need to be answered about each of those options in order to evaluate their feasibility, costs, and benefits
- Determine legitimate methods for gaining answers to those questions
- Jointly review and interpret the data that comes back, and
- Evaluate the options based on the new information.
Two additional goals of the WTOP are to:
- Improve relationships and effective communication among the Town officials, affected families, and other members of the town
- Provide an arena for public information and input and transparent deliberation and evaluation
The core interests at stake include:
- Health, safety and well-being of impacted abutters
- Property rights and economic impacts on property for abutters
- Implementation of Falmouth’s climate action protection plan goals to reduce use of fossil fuel
- Fiscal impacts on the town’s taxpayers and town services
- An amicable end to a conflict that has divided and challenged the town’s relationships and reputation
Any broadly acceptable long-term plan for the turbines will need to respond to some extent to all of these core interests.
The participants represent the following interests:
- 5 residents primarily concerned with adverse impacts of the turbines on neighbors, including health and economic impacts
- 2 residents primarily concerned with implementing Falmouth’s climate action protection plan to reduce use of fossil fuel
- 2 taxpayers primarily concerned with the Town of Falmouth's fiscal well-being
- 2 residents with strong empathy for all perspectives. These representatives are primarily concerned with a fair and effective process that may lead to an amicable outcome and reunite the town
- 3 Town Departments
- 2 liaisons from the Board of Selectmen attend all meetings and are available to answer questions, but do not participate at the table
Facilitated by Stacie Smith (stacie@cbuilding.org) and Eric Roberts (eroberts@cbuilding.org).
Click on a date below to view and download the related meeting materials.
Meetings
Draft AgendaFinal Meeting Summary
Meeting Twenty Presentation Slides - Stacie Smith Brief Summary of Acentech Report: Wind Turbine Sound Modeling - Eric W. Wood and James D. BarnesSurvey Findings
Handouts
Acentech's Falmouth Wind Turbine Modeling Report, Nov. 20, 2012MassCEC Update for Falmouth WTOP, Nov. 20, 2012
Draft AgendaFinal Meeting Summary
Handouts (emailed)
Final Survey LetterFinal SurveySummary CalculationsSummary Calculations Round 2PV Cash Flow Analysis
Presentations
Draft Revenue, Expense and Cash Flow Analysis - Sustainable Energy Advantage, LLC;
Updated Cash Flow Presentation
Draft Updated Wind Turbine Curtailment Scenarios - DNV KEMA
Draft AgendaFinal Meeting Summary
Handouts
Summary of Craggy Ridge Wind Turbine Survey ResultsPackagesNotes from WTOP Members, Oppenheim and David with Craggy Ridge Neighborhood Association
Presentations
Meeting Fourteen Presentation Slides - Stacie SmithOverview Presentation for Craggy Ridge - Jeff Oppenheim & Linda DavisShadow Flicker Impact Analysis Presentation - Peter McPhee
Draft AgendaFinal Meeting Summary
See "Board of Health Hearing Testimonies" under "Information Requests" to the right.
